Voices

A day of mourning each November

I have been asked more than once to participate in civic Thanksgiving services. And more than once, I’ve declined.

It’s Thanksgiving time again. Across the nation, people will gather for ecumenical, interfaith, and civic services of gratitude, prayer, and reflection. Someone may read Abraham Lincoln’s Thanksgiving proclamation; a school choir may sing; village officials and local religious leaders may speak. And often a Native American from the community is asked to give a land acknowledgment or read a poem.

I’ve been asked to be that person more than once, because I’m a tribal citizen who is also a Christian minister. And more than once, I’ve declined. Inviting a Native person helps perpetuate the myth of the first Thanksgiving, of a happy harvest meal shared between the tribal people of the Eastern Seaboard and the settlers of the Plymouth Colony. The Native person is invited to participate in a performance of shared gratitude, glossing over the question of whether the arrival of the Pilgrims was entirely innocent. I’m not interested in perpetuating that myth.

The myth owes less to any historically reliable account than it does to the painting The First Thanksgiving 1621, one of a series Jean Leon Gerome Ferris created in the early 20th century to depict US history and life. Because these paintings were reproduced and widely distributed, many Americans have seen The First Thanksgiving. It depicts an aproned Pilgrim woman graciously serving bread to a group of Native men seated on the ground. To her right, a group of Pilgrims and a man dressed as a conquistador gather around a table. The Native men are depicted in stereotypical dress associated with 19th-century Northern Plains tribes. A Native woman in a buckskin dress stands in the background as a Pilgrim woman speaks over her shoulder, seeming to offer some kind of instruction. On the perimeter, Pilgrim men with muskets watch sternly.