This project by producers Paul Marsteller and Gabriel Rhodes is an admirable tribute to pre–World War I popular music. Each singer is accompanied only by instruments from the song’s period. Richard Thomson’s sly baritone curls around “The Band Played On” like a handlebar mustache, while Graham Parker tackles “The Flying Trapeze” with saloon-and-sarsaparilla panache. And Jolie Goodnight’s “I Love You Truly”—crooned to the accompaniment of violin, piano and brushes—conjures visions of men in bowlers.
The Beautiful Old, by various artists
This review appears in the June 26, 2013 issue.

