Less brutal than that one time

Chicago mayor Rahm Emanuel says that the Chicago Police Department "did a tremendous job” keeping the peace during the NATO summit this week. President Obama agrees.

Chicago Indymedia offers another perspective, posting videos of protestors surrounded by police and brutally beaten. A lively comment-field debate follows, complete with the predictable name-calling but also with this more levelheaded comment by a purported eyewitness:

The announcer on the stage told people that as they dispersed they should do so to the west and most people did, or at least tried to. There were a select few who chose to push in to the police and unfortunately they were many others in between the two groups who got caught in the middle and had no where else to go. There were hundreds and hundreds of police completely surrounding for blocks. You couldn't walk in the street and had to exit on the sidewalks. So while all this chaos is going on try filtering thousands of people down two 3-4 foot wide sidewalks. . . . Once the violence started, there was no differentiation on the part of the police between those causing the problems and those just with reach. There were people with their backs turned getting hit with clubs, and then when they were down on the ground you would see an officer from 3 or 4 feet away take a shot just because they could. Were the police 100% unprovoked, no; however the reaction was very very very extreme.