If there is one thing that characterizes our current moment for me, it is precarity. The sense that everything is up for grabs is advanced by the arbitrary, capricious nature of our current leadership. President Trump recently argued that he is not bound by the frameworks of international law, but is instead only restrained by “his mind.” As we watch our military attack Iran and ICE terrorize our own communities, it’s hard to argue that the world order that Americans once trusted is holding.
But a quick look through scripture shows that following the sacred story of God’s involvement in our world is not without a fear that God could be arbitrary. There is perhaps no better moment of this whiplash than when God commands Abraham to sacrifice his only son Isaac, the very basis of God’s promise to make Abraham’s descendents into a nation that will bless the world, only to pull back at the last moment and offer up a ram as an appropriate sacrificial substitute. The passage is full of dread and has proposed a problem for generations of readers who grapple with what it might reveal about the nature of God. Why would God put Abraham through something that just amounts to a test of loyalty?
My favorite interpretation of this event comes from Marilynne Robinson’s Reading Genesis. Robinson reminds us that child sacrifice was a common expectation of Near Eastern deity worship. In this context, God is not asking anything out of the ordinary. But by offering a substitute, God says that God is not like these other deities. She even gets into the psychology of the text in ways that I appreciate: “Now Abraham knows that the most passionate worshippers of Moloch or Anat are not more devout than he. The most excruciating sacrifice they made was no greater than the one he would have made if God Himself had not forbidden it.”

