In the Lectionary

November 22, Reign of Christ A (Matthew 25:31–46)

It can be shockingly obvious when you encounter someone who has voluntarily doused their own human light.

It’s fascinating to me how easy it is to label one person a sheep and another a goat. I’ll readily admit that when I encounter this week’s gospel passage, names and faces come to mind almost reflexively. The particular people change over the years, but the immediate response is always there: the certainty of someone’s livestock identity. And why not? There have always been people whose woolly coat or shaggy beard is visible to the naked eye.

The taxonomy in the text is simple enough. Did you compassionately meet the basic needs of other people—food, shelter, clothing, medical care—or did you choose not to? Did you advocate for them, or did you leave them adrift? Did you protect them when they were vulnerable, or did you harm and abuse them? Did you respect their basic dignity, or did you humiliate them? Did you treat human beings with the respect due God’s creation, or did you treat them as disposable things?

Of course, first you have to know what a sheep or a goat actually might have looked like in a culture in which people often lived right snug among their livestock. Everyone listening to Jesus speak could distinguish between any goat and any sheep at a glance, as nearly everyone (maybe not royalty, of course) bumped into a sheep or goat every day of their lives since birth. The shepherd doing the separating isn’t spending time judging the goatness or sheepness of each individual animal; they’re parting a pile with as much certainty as I have separating cauliflower from broccoli. After enough encounters with produce stands, you just know.