Judge me

There's a saying that's come to have popular acceptance in American faith discourse: my faith is between me and God.

We've been hearing a bunch of that lately, particularly from those seeking power, who bristle at the idea that anyone has a right to call their assertions of faith into question.

What right does anyone have to judge the faith of anyone else? Faith is spiritual, this one-on-one relationship between you and The Cosmic Kahuna, and no-one has a right to critique what is an entirely private matter.  Faith, and Christian faith in particular, is just a "personal relationship." It is separate from every other relationship we have.