NYPD's Muslim surveillance extended well beyond New York

c. 2012 Religion News Service
NEWARK, N.J. (RNS) The report was stamped top secret.
Inside was a confidential dossier compiled by the New York Police
Department documenting "locations of concern" in Newark -- the city's 44 mosques,
Muslim-owned restaurants and businesses and Islamic schools.

In 2007, the NYPD began an undercover spy operation within New Jersey's
largest city to find and document where Muslims lived, worked and prayed.
Now, city officials and many of those targeted are voicing anger at the
disclosures, which came in the wake of an Associated Press report showing
that a secret NYPD surveillance program aimed at Muslims had extended well
beyond New York City.

"I have deep concerns and I am very disturbed that this might have been
surveillance that was based on no more than religious affiliation," Newark
Mayor Cory Booker said.

Booker said he had been unaware of the undercover work and the Newark
Police Department -- which had been contacted by the NYPD early on -- had not
been involved in any joint operations.

"What we are discovering appears to be an NYPD operation in our city that
involved the blanket surveillance of Newark residents and workers based
solely on the religion of those individuals," he said. "If this is indeed what
transpired, it is, I believe, a clear infringement on the core liberties
of our citizenry."

Separately, the American Civil Liberties Union of New Jersey immediately
demanded a further investigation by the state attorney general, calling it a
"violation of the public trust."

Since the 9/11 terrorist attacks, the NYPD has been methodically compiling
data on the region's Muslim populations, infiltrating mosques and student
groups, and building profiles of local ethnic groups.

But new reports on the extent of that surveillance operation revealed the
NYPD had been operating well outside its jurisdiction, cataloging Muslim
communities on Long Island and New Jersey, and monitoring Muslim college
students across the region.

New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg has strongly defended his department.
"The police department goes where there are allegations. And they look to
see whether those allegations are true," he told reporters on Tuesday (Feb.
21). "That's what you'd expect them to do. That's what you'd want them to
do. Remind yourself when you turn out the light tonight."

In Newark, the NYPD apparently cataloged every mosque and Muslim-owned
business in the city -- from fried-chicken joints to houses of worship located
in private homes.

There was no mention of terrorism or any criminal wrongdoing in the
60-page report, obtained by The Associated Press, which described the aim of the
surveillance as compiling "the existence of population centers and business
districts of communities of interest."

Most of the properties listed in the NYPD report were Islamic cultural
centers, restaurants and stores where members of Newark's Muslim community
went to pray, eat or shop.

The report carries the tone of a dispassionate tour guide. A page on
Newark Fried Chicken said the restaurant was owned and operated by Afghans.
"Location is in good location and has seating capacity for 10 to 15 customers,"
the report said.

An entry for Masjid Fallahee labeled it a private house where 25 to 30
worshippers of Nigerian and West African ethnicities had been seen in prayer.
Inside the Islamic Cultural Center, Abdul Khabir called the NYPD
investigation "unfortunate" but said it did not bother him because he had nothing to
hide. "We just want to serve Allah," Khabir said.

At the Dollar Deal store on Broad Street, 25-year-old Watas Ali struggled
to understand why his business was involved in a police probe.

"They separate us from other businesses just because we're Muslim?" he
asked. "It's unfair."

Abu Muhmad, a senior administrator at the Masjid Rahmah, a mosque on Dr.
Martin Luther King Jr. Boulevard, said reports of surveillance are not a
revelation to him. He said FBI agents had been coming to the mosque for years.
"We know for a fact agents are out there listening to what is being said
at prayers," particularly on Fridays, when hundreds come to pray at the
mosque, he said.

But, like several who came for prayers yesterday, Muhmad said mosque
leaders accepted the scrutiny as a sign of the times, however unfortunate.
"We understand the situation," he said.

One member of the mosque, however, Abdur Rahman, called the surveillance
effort offensive. "It's crazy," Rahman said as the mosque's amplified call
to prayer sounded outside. "It's a form of stereotyping. It's stupid."
City Councilman Anibal Ramos Jr. labeled the disclosures shocking.

"Newark is a town that's made up of folks from all over the world," he
said. "Every resident has a right to have their privacy protected," he said.
"Unless they're targeted for a specific investigation, then I don't

David Giambusso

David Giambusso writes for the Star-Ledger of New Jersey.

All articles »

James Queally

James Queally writes for The Star-Ledger in Newark.

All articles »