Muslim seminary ends talks with Vatican over pope's comments

VATICAN CITY (RNS) The most prestigious religious university in the
Sunni Muslim world has suspended dialogue with the Vatican to protest
statements by Pope Benedict XVI denouncing violence against Christians
in Egypt.

The move, on Thursday (Jan. 20), came only nine days after Egypt
recalled its ambassador to the Vatican for the same reason.

Sheikh Ahmed El-Tayeb, the grand imam of Cairo's Al-Azhar
University, and members of the university's Islamic Research Center made
the decision at an "emergency meeting" on Thursday, according to a
statement released by the center.

"Pope Benedict's repeated criticism of Islam and his unjustified
claim that Copts are persecuted in Egypt and the Middle East were behind
the suspension decision," said the statement, as translated on the
Website of the Dubai-based Gulf News.

On Jan. 2, Benedict denounced the "vile and murderous" New Year's
Day killing of at least 21 people by a car bomb outside a Christian
Coptic church in Alexandria, Egypt.

Al-Azhar's El-Tayeb had immediately criticized the pope's statement
as "unacceptable interference in Egypt's affairs."

"I disagree with the pope's view," El-Tayeb said at the time, "and I
ask why did the pope not call for the protection of Muslims when they
were subjected to killings in Iraq?"

Benedict mentioned the attack again, along with other killings of
Christians in the Middle East, during an address to foreign ambassadors
at the Vatican on Jan. 10, when he called on "governments of the region
to adopt ... effective measures for the protection of religious

The day after Benedict's speech to the diplomats, the government of
Egypt recalled its ambassador to the Vatican to protest what a spokesman
called the pope's "unacceptable interference in (Egypt's) internal

Francis X. Rocca

Francis X. Rocca writes for Religion News Service.

All articles »