Even after win, gay clergy likely to remain limited
(RNS) Gay and lesbian advocates celebrated a landmark victory on Tuesday
(May 10) when the Presbyterian Church (USA) entered the expanding ranks
of Christian denominations that allow openly gay, partnered clergy.
The winds of change, they said, are at their backs.
"Presbyterians join a growing Protestant movement of Lutherans,
Episcopalians and United Church of Christ members who have eliminated
official barriers to leadership by lesbian, gay, bisexual and
transgender persons," a coalition of pro-gay Presbyterians said in a
The momentum of the gay clergy movement, however, may soon grind to
"There is not another denomination I see on the horizon right now
that is on the cusp of this," said Robert P. Jones, CEO of Public
Religion Research Institute, a nonpartisan research and consulting firm.
Officially, the PCUSA's decades-old barrier will fall in July, after
Presbyterians in Minnesota voted to effectively revoke a rule that had
barred sexually active gays and lesbians from becoming ministers, elders
The new policy, which was passed by the church's General Assembly
last summer, required approval from a majority of 173 regional
presbyteries. Since 1997, three similar amendments had failed at the
Lisa Larges, a San Francisco lesbian blocked from pursuing
ordination for 25 years, called Tuesday's vote "a new beginning," for
her calling and her church. "With this vote, our church is demonstrating
that we are choosing to reach out to a new generation," Larges said.
But even as gay and lesbian Christians celebrated, some acknowledged
that steep challenges lie ahead in other denominations, particularly the
country's largest four: the Roman Catholic Church, the Southern Baptist
Convention, the United Methodist Church, and the Church of Jesus Christ
of Latter-day Saints.
Those four denominations, whose leaders show few signs of accepting
gay clergy or relationships, together count nearly 100 million members.
By contrast, the four largest denominations that allow gay clergy
together count less than 11 million members. The Presbyterian Church
(USA), for example, has about 2.1 million members.
"I do think there is momentum on this," said the Rev. Rebecca
Voelkel, a UCC minister and director of the church component of the
National Gay and Lesbian Task Force. "But I don't think it's going to
happen with lightening speed, and I don't think it's inevitable." she
Gay rights activists in the United Methodist Church, for example,
have labored in vain for years to remove a rule that calls homosexuality
"incompatible with Christian teaching," and bars the ordination of
non-celibate gays and lesbians.
According to a 2008 survey conducted by the Public Religion Research
Institute, just 32 percent of Methodist ministers want to allow gay
"The data would not suggest that United Methodist clergy are on the
cusp of supporting gay and lesbian ordination," Jones said.
Moreover, the UMC, which has about 12 million members worldwide, is
growing most rapidly in Africa, where Christians tend to hold
conservative views on theology and sexuality, noted Alan Wisdom, vice
president of the Institute for Religion and Democracy, a
Washington-based conservative think tank.
And while polls show American lay Catholics becoming more accepting
of homosexuality, the hierarchy remains staunchly opposed. In fact, the
Vatican mounted an investigation aimed at eradicating "homosexual
behavior" from U.S. seminaries after the clergy sexual abuse scandal
exploded in 2002.
The Mormon church, with about 6 million U.S. members, does not have
full-time clergy, but said last year that celibate gay Mormons who are
"worthy and qualified in every other way" should be allowed to have
"callings," or church assignments.
However, the church still says homosexuality "violates the
commandments of God, is contrary to the purposes of human sexuality, and
deprives people of the blessings that can be found in family life and in
the saving ordinances of the gospel."
Jones and other social scientists say young evangelicals are more
gay-friendly than previous generations. But the nation's largest
evangelical denomination, the 16-million-member Southern Baptist
Convention, has dug in its heels.
Homosexuality is "prohibited and condemned in both the Old and New
Testaments," the SBC said in a 2009 resolution. The resolution, which
passed by a wide margin, also calls gay marriage "diametrically opposed
to God's word."