Court says Adventist postmen can't get Saturday off

April 4, 2011

(RNS) Neither snow nor rain nor Saturday Sabbaths should keep a Missouri
mailman from his appointed rounds, a federal appeals court has ruled.

Seventh-day Adventist Hosea Harrell argued he was the victim of
religious discrimination when the U.S. Postal Service refused to give
him Saturdays off. Harrell took the days off anyway and was fired in

Like Jews, Seventh-day Adventists observe the Sabbath from sundown
Friday to sundown Saturday, and believe the day should be kept holy by
refraining from secular work.

But the 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, upholding a lower court
decision, ruled that giving Harrell Saturdays off would create an "undue
hardship" for his fellow mail carriers and the post office where he

"This accommodation would have burdened other letter carriers with
more Saturday work at least in part because they did not share Harrell's
religious beliefs," wrote Circuit Judge Bobby Shepherd.

Also, the Warrensburg post office schedule is determined by
seniority and could not have been changed without violating a collective
bargaining agreement with a mail carriers' union, according to Shepherd.
Harrell was the most junior letter carrier.

The six other mail carriers were asked to give up their Saturdays
but declined. Harrell was offered a different position with the USPS and
leave to attend church services on Saturday, but rejected both offers,
according to Shepherd. The routes could not have been covered using
fewer carries, the USPS argued.