Black churches may no longer be at center of civil rights protest

December 18, 2014

Half a century after civil rights movement activists marched across the South, the black church is finding new routes for activism. But often, its clergy admit, churches are not leaders, and sanctuaries are no longer ground zero for the civil rights movement.

On December 14, which some churches dubbed “Black Lives Matter” Sunday, many people in the pews found themselves playing catch-up with the people who had already been on the streets.

Thousands of black churches—prompted initially by leaders of three historically black denominations and later joined by officials of mostly white and Hispanic faith groups—marked the day with black suits and dresses, litanies, and prayers to be counted among the throngs of Americans decrying recent grand jury decisions not to indict white police officers in the killings of unarmed black men.

Delman Coates, pastor of Mount Ennon Baptist Church in Clinton, Mary­land, spearheaded the first conference of the progressive Black Church Center for Justice and Equality earlier in December.

“I hope that we can build the sentiment,” he said, “to really reclaim this tradition of activism and social justice advocacy, which is really at the heart of the black church.”

Coates and others say the black church—which he defines as a movement committed to freedom, not just a group of African-American worshipers—is being challenged by a number of factors, including young people who are not drawn to their pews and gay activists who are pushing for more welcoming attitudes from churches.

In a statement responding to the “Black Lives Matter” campaign, young adults of the African Methodist Epis­copal Church urged its members to “find ways to connect with young adults who are not in our churches” and address their needs.

“Let us not become comfortable in places or spaces of privilege as our privilege is only of worth if it serves as a platform to challenge the status quo,” they wrote.

African-American churches also struggle with whether to focus on only black concerns or on a broader range of issues. When some said they were going to focus specifically on praying for black males on that Sunday, women and gay activists called for greater inclusion.

“Black LGBT bodies must matter, too!” said a statement from Many Voices, an LGBT church group. 

Alton B. Pollard III, dean of Howard University’s School of Divinity, said, “It really makes for some of our congregations to be betwixt and between.”

Jacquelyn Dupont-Walker, director of the AME Church’s Social Action Com­mis­sion, said the challenges reflect a generational divide and a wider disconnect that needs to be bridged.

“We’ve become aware that the isms that the young people want to approach are broader than the isms that the historic black church is focused on,” she said.

The upcoming movie Selma depicts the Alabama voting rights marches led by Martin Luther King Jr. and other clergy, but today’s ministers acknowledge that they have a different role.

“I think what history is going to record is that this is the first movement in black history that’s not been led by the church or by a religious figure,” said Jamal Harrison Bryant, pastor of Baltimore’s Empower­ment Temple, whose members marched to a nearby mall after Decem­ber 14 Sunday services for a “die-in” protest. “The church is jumping in to lend its support—not to lead it—which is a different place from where the black church has been historically.”

Even as leaders of the black church grapple with their roles and plan activism around updated legislation and police policies, new LifeWay Research surveys show that black clergy may have to lead the charge themselves.

Two-thirds of U.S. adults say religious leaders offer a positive role in the country’s race relations. The vast majority of African-American pastors (93 percent) said their churches were involved in racial reconciliation, compared with 71 percent of white pastors.

Leaders of the AME, AME Zion, and Christian Methodist Episcopal churches plan to continue discussing strategy to carve out their place in the latest cries for equal treatment.

“To assume we are at the forefront is erroneous,” said Lawrence Reddick, senior bishop of the CME Church. “We certainly should participate, and if people call us to leadership, we certainly should take the role of leadership. But leadership has to be earned by people who look at us and want to follow.”

And, he added, for some black clergy this may take some adjustment: “It may be a change we don’t all want to accept.” —Religion News Service

This article was edited on January 5, 2014.