Church historian sees Catholic schism ahead

Influential church historian Diarmaid MacCulloch said he believes that Christianity faces a bright future but predicts that the Roman Catholic Church will undergo a major schism over its moral and social teaching.

“Christianity, the world’s largest religion, is rapidly expanding—by all indications, its future is very bright,” said MacCulloch, 60, professor of church history at Oxford University and an Anglican deacon.

MacCulloch’s observations are spelled out in his book to be published in the spring by Penguin UK. He told the Century that the book’s provisional title is Listening, Praying, Forgetting: A History of Christian Silence.

In an interview with ENInews, he said, “Conflict in religion is inevitable and usually healthy—a religion without conflict is a religion that will die.” But, he added, conflicts “are particularly serious in the Roman Catholic Church, which seems on the verge of a very great split over the Vatican’s failure to listen to European Catholics.”

He predicted that Catholicism faces a division over attempts by popes John Paul II and Benedict XVI to “rewrite the story” of the 1962–1965 Second Vatican Council. Those two popes have portrayed Vatican II as a “minor adjustment” in church governance, rather than as a “radical move to change the way authority is ex­pressed,” MacCulloch said.

“But the stance of the popes has produced an angry reaction among those who want to see the council continue,” he said. “No other church in history has ever made all its clergy celibate. It’s a peculiarity of the Western Latin church, and it looks increasingly unrealistic.”

The Vatican’s refusal to allow Roman Catholics to talk about married or female clergy was “not the reaction of a rational body,” MacCulloch said.

MacCulloch, a specialist in early modern history and a fellow of the British Academy, coedits the Cambridge-based Journal of Ecclesiastical History and was knighted in early 2012 for services to scholarship.

Among numerous awards, he was the 2010 recipient of the Cundill Prize in History from Montreal’s McGill University for his 2009 book Christianity: The First Three Thousand Years, which was accompanied by a BBC television series. —ENI

Jonathan Luxmoore

Jonathan Luxmoore writes for Ecumenical News International.

All articles »