Clashes and coalitions: Christians and Muslims in Egypt

March 16, 2011
Photo by Brooke Comar. Photos below by Ben Robinson and Yasmine Perni.

On March 11, the one-month anniversary of former President Mubarak's resignation, thousands of Egyptians took to the streets of Cairo, Port Said and Alexandria to celebrate national unity and condemn sectarianism. The march was called by the same youth coalition that launched the revolution. This time their slogan was "No to sectarian strife."

Egyptians from all spectrums of society were waving flags and banners reading "Muslims and Christians are one." Hundreds of people held up crosses and copies of the Qur'an, chanting "Christians and Muslims are one hand." Around the country, Muslim imams addressed religious harmony in their Friday sermons. In Cairo's Tahrir Square, an army general stood on the makeshift platform and lifted high the cross and the Qur'an, saying to the massive crowed, "The crescent and the cross are one. We are all Egyptians, Muslim and Christian." In the now world-famous square, Muslims and Christians prayed together for the unity and safety of Egypt.

It was a peaceful and profoundly heartwarming day. Yet these unity marches came after days of sectarian violence in Egypt that included the burning of a church south of Cairo and clashes between hundreds, if not thousands, of young Christians and Muslims. In an impoverished Cairo suburb, 13 people were killed and more than 140 injured.

What is going on? How could Egyptian Christians be attacked and a church burnt after Muslims and Christians stood, fought and died together in Tahrir Square, where images of solidarity between both faiths stirred the whole world? Just over a month ago, in a sign of unity, Christians held a mass in Tahrir Square as Muslim protesters formed a ring around them to protect them during the service. Christians did the same for Muslims as they prayed.

As is often the case within outbreaks of religious violence, the immediate reasons are complex and local. The recent tensions originated in the village of Sol in Etfeeh, 90 kilometers south of Cairo. A conflict had been brewing for months after it was discovered that a Christian man had fallen in love with a Muslim woman. To clear the Muslim family's name, a cousin in the family murdered the Muslim woman's father, which led to the woman's brother (the son of the murdered father) avenging the death of his father by killing his cousin. During the emotional funeral, some Muslims blamed Christians for the murders, and they were incited to attack the nearby church, known as the "Two Martyr's Church." The church was torched, and some Christians fled their homes in fear.

On March 7, Coptic Christians from the Manshiyet Nasr neighborhood of Cairo, a predominately Christian area that is home to the city's garbage collectors, took to the streets to protest the burning of the Sol village church. Some one thousand young Copts held a demonstration to voice their anger, blocking two main roads and bringing traffic on the east side of Cairo to a halt for two hours. Even though their priest, knowing the potential for conflict, begged them to stop, the men continued, burning tires and throwing rocks at passing cars.

Muslims from the adjacent neighborhood heard that the Copts had already burned down a small mosque and were coming to burn down the iconic Sayyida Aisha mosque. Violent clashes erupted. Molotov cocktails and stones were thrown back and forth throughout the night before the army was able to calm the situation. Seven Christians and five Muslims where killed, with more than one hundred injured, in clashes that lasted into the early morning of the following day. Several Coptic homes and businesses in the area were also torched.

But the priest from the area where the violence took place told the press that this was not a clash between Muslims and Christians. "The attack was organized and [involved] guns," he said. "Muslim residents [here] don't have weapons."

His comments reflect a widespread view regarding this sectarian strife: that it is being orchestrated by pro-Mubarak members of the State Security and by members of Mubarak's National Democratic Party, bent on revenge and counterrevolution.

The former ruling party took advantage of all weaknesses in the society, seeking to guide people's anger and keep their legitimate frustrations at bay. Most Egyptians see the recent religious conflicts as a counterrevolution plan targeting Coptic Christians, as they are the most vulnerable and hence the easiest to mobilize against. By creating chaos, instability and confusion, the secret police and the thugs of the former ruling party aim to make possible the return of the former regime in coming elections.

On the recent "day of national unity," Sheikh Muzhir Shahin from Omar Makram mosque delivered the sermon in Tahrir Square. He warned of "hidden hands that are trying to ruin the nation" by breeding tension between Muslims and Christians in order "to incite sectarian tensions and waste the gains of the revolution." There is recent evidence that the state security has infiltrated the Salafist movement (which promotes a fundamentalist interpretation of Islam) and is using it to try to provoke a counterrevolution. It was the Salafis who clashed with the Copts last week in Cairo.

Other religious and political leaders agree that a state security plot is underway. Bishop Theodyssius of Giza, where the Great Pyramids are located, said that those who burned the church in the village of Sol were "thugs and outlaws" attempting to cause division and subversion. Father Filopateer, also of the Giza diocese, insisted that the use of the words "sectarian tension" to depict the conflict is incorrect. He sees the violence as instances of criminal acts, not the result of religious tensions. The new prime minister, Essam Sharaf, warned this last week of a counterrevolution threatening the country with sectarian strife and subverting the nation's progress. 

The Muslim Brotherhood, the largest opposition group in Egypt, has blamed the remnants of Mubarak's regime for the recent religious clashes. In a statement, the group said, "These people are operating under the principle of 'divide to conquer' and have incited a group of Muslim extremists to bring up other sectarian issues." Even the Islamic cleric Sheikh Youssef al-Qaradawi, president of the International Union of Islamic Scholars, publicly condemned the attack on the Coptic church, describing it as "the work of the devil." Al-Qaradawi asked Egyptians to support the new government and called on different religious groups to unite in rebuilding the country.

The outcry against the sectarian tension—from almost all parties and religious groups in Egypt—has been most impressive. Many concrete acts of support and solidarity have been shown toward Coptic Christians as well.

The January 25 Revolution Youth Coalition sent representatives to visit the village of Sol in Etfeeh, where they met with political and religious figures in the village to help bring calm to the situation. The coalition has also rounded up more than a thousand volunteers to assist in the rebuilding of the church. Many Muslims have also joined in solidarity with Copts who are protesting through a sit-in in front of the state television headquarters in Cairo.

Following up on their promise to rebuild the burned church and bring those behind the attack to justice, the Supreme Council of the Armed Forces began reconstruction work on March 13. Sheikh Ahmed El-Tayeb, the Grand Imam of Al-Azhar (the intellectual and spiritual heart of Sunni Islam), announced that he will personally visit the village and promised that Muslims will help in the reconstruction of the church.

The most prominent visit to Sol was from a special delegation of key Muslim and Coptic figures, including famous Salafi Muslim cleric Sheikh Mohamed Hassan, Coptic political activist George Ishaq and Muslim Brotherhood leader Mohamed Al-Beltagy. They met the heads of the Muslim and Christian families and visited Copts' houses. But perhaps most moving of all was the visit by television lay preachers Amr Khaled, one of the most popular preachers in the Muslim world (he is often called the "Muslim Billy Graham"). A week after the church burning, Khaled preached in the main mosque in Sol, challenging his listeners as follows: "And my message here today for Mulsims and the Christians is: Let's be one hand. Each one of the people here in Sol has to do something. First we must each stop this problem in our own homes." Many villagers responded to Khaled by chanting slogans calling for unity.

The interfaith youth movement that led the revolution paved the way for the future. While it may be a long and hard road to a new Egypt, the unity demonstrations were an encouraging counter to the sectarian violence of last week. The spirit of interfaith solidarity is still alive. It was notably illustrated at the close of Prime Minister Sharaf's nationwide television interview. Tearing up, Sharaf mentioned that he had just received two phone calls, one immediately following the other. The first was from an Egyptian on the Muslim pilgrimage (Hajj) in Saudi Arabia who promised to pray for him. The second was from a Christian friend of his son's who said that he and his fiancée light a candle every day for him in prayer.


A shorter version of this article appears in the April 5 print edition.


The root causes of sectarian violence and discrimination

This is what the "Islamists" (e.g., Muslim brotherhoods, and other smart/wicked violent Islamic groups) and their crowd/supporters want you (especially the non-Arab) to believe. It is part of a false/smart/wicked propaganda!
We (minorities, and minority Christian Egypt, specifically) are used to these types of false and misguided commentaries (that aim to make people feel good, falsely, at the expense of the true victims of such horrific acts). Whenever a church is burned, it is the act of a crazy or mentally sick person(s). Whenever a group of Christians killed, it s a personal matter/conflict with their Muslim neighbors! Nothing has to do with certain violent Islamic teaching! Nothing has to do with Islamists' pressure and aggression against Christians! Nothing has to do with certain teachings (or fatwas, or call for jihad) and interpretation of Islamic Shari'a. At the end of the day, Americans are comforted because someone has written something to make them feel good and comfortable.

How did the writer know that the perpetrators were Mubarak's thugs? If the perpetrators were 'Mubarak thugs", how many thugs are prosecuted? And, how many of these thugs were determined to be Mubarak's thugs? None so far!!

There are many ways for violent group(s) of the majority to harass the minority. In the case of burning the church( in Helwan, suburb of Cairo) earlier this month, the TRUE reason was Muslims' anger because a young Christian boy fell in love with a young Muslim girl. Isalmicly, this brings immense shame to Muslims and Islam; consequently, Christians should pay a heavy price for it. This is not the first case (has nothing to do with Mubarak or "Mubarak's thugs") and it won't be the last. If the case is reversed (a young Muslim boy fall in love with a young Christian girl) nothing will happen.
Another example: a rumor that Christians have burned a mosques (never happened.. never..); then Muslim must rise to defend the honor or Islam by burning/ destroying churches and Christians' homes. The same false story! Same rumor! It happened frequently in the past.
Another example: Islamist thugs, in January 2010, separated Christians from Muslim in a train, and started to spray Christians with bullets.
Another example: bombing and burning a church in Rafah (in Sinai) last month.
Another example: bombing a church in Alexandria during the new year ever mass,killing more than 25 and injuring more than 100. On January 6, 2010 (The Christmas Eve in Egypt) Muslim terrorists sprayed Christian worshipers with bullets on the door-steps of a church in Nag-Hammadi killing seven young men. the story repeats it self almost every year.
Another example: killing a priest and a deacon in Assyout (200 miles south of Cairo) it Last month.
When Muslim burned the church in Helwan (suburb of Cairo) recently, the army was there; the army did not interfere; when Muslims shouted "Allah Akbar" every time they hit the church with sledgehammers, the army was there! When the Muslim sheikh said he will lead the Muslims in prayer in the location of the destroyed church, the army was there! The people who burned the church and destroyed it still live in the village freely without prosecution. They became Mujahideen, for burning the church (that is used by Kafir polytheist Christians) and forcing the Christians out of the village.
Another example: the recent killing some Christians during a rally in the Garbage Quarter in Cairo (protesting the burning of the church in Helwan) with huge bullets penetrating their bodies (if anyone wants to see the images I will show them to you).
Another example: the military attacked a monastery because the monks tried to build a fence to protect themselves, last month.
In all cases, causes, and rumors, the stories end with burning churches, killing Christians, kidnapping Christian women and girls, forcing Christians to convert to Islam, destroying Christians properties, or any combinations of them. Furthermore, in all cases the story ends with Christian and Muslim reconciling and became brothers, again! And, the enemies of the state - crazy Muslim citizens, Zionists, Israeli agents, etc.- are usual target to blame.
The tensions and the terrorization of Christians will continue in Egypt until the government and Egyptian people searches for the real internal causes, including certain violent Islamic teaching (endorsed and practiced by "Islamists" and Islamic groups) against non-Muslim minorities in Egypt, and in other dominant Muslims societies too. Egypt is one of many other examples that include Ira, Iran, Pakistan, Sudan, Saudi Arabia, etc.
Reality (especially in collective and oppressive societies) is much worse than what some people claim it to be. Some people love to beautify and justify certain violent and oppressive acts; however, they should not do that at the expense of the victims. Doing so, they contribute to victimize the victims further.
We all (Christians and Muslims) rallied in the street of Egypt on January 25; we all want better future for our children! And, when the rallies ended, we started to face the same ugly daily discrimination, harassment, and terror, again, by Islamists and violent Islamic groups and Islamist thugs.
We (Christian minority in Egypt) have been subject to these many forms of discrimination for years, decades, and centuries. I don't think they will stop now because Mubarak resigned! It is deeper and more complex than that.
Last comment: If you really search for the truth, start by asking the victims.
Adel Abadeer,

Mr. Adel - be Fair and free yourself

Assalamu Alaikum Mr. Adel,
I have read the article that descries Egypt I know, I am not sure how long you been out of Egypt or about the source of your information. However, the article is more authentic than your commentary that is full of allegations and accusation need to be verified.

The article is exposing those who are trying (like your commentary) to continue this fire that was used by previous regime to keep their grime power on our beloved country of Egypt.

As we saw the previous regime vanished and collapsed in front of the truth, we will see those who are trying to keep the fire burning, we will see them going at the same path like Mubarak and his thugs. I pray that you fairly and freely examined your thought with the new Egypt that we are experiencing and free yourself and give a chance to think away from, Zakariya Morqos and those like him who are trying tirelessly to keep the fire burning for those own sake.

We are Muslims and Christians from the same country and we will continue to enjoy this beloved country of ours. God Bless,,
Hamdy Radwan,

Long on Kerygma, Short on Analysis

The story published above is clearly an attempt, as a previous commenter stated, intended to make people feel good. It is very reassuring.

But the overall picture coming out of Egypt is one of increased fear on the part of Coptic Christians and increased aggressiveness on the part of their antagonists in Egyptian society, who are motivated by Islamic teachings regarding non-Muslims and the role they ought to play in Muslim-majority countries.

Yes, indeed, there are many Muslims who are attempting to change how Egypt treats its Coptic minority, but the situation is much more dire than this correspondent indicates.

This type of coverage raises questions about whether there can ever be such a thing as credible religious journalism. The desire to work stories into a neat little narrative that confirms the Kerygma of God's presence in history seems to overwhelm the ability of Christian Century and other publications in the U.S. to provide reliable coverage of events as they unfold.

The author has cherry picked events to affirm a pleasant religious drama that has little credibility as a piece of journalism.