Baptist scholar says remember Appalachia before it disappears
ASHEVILLE, N.C. (ABP) -- Dynamite pulling down mountain tops and
satellite dishes pulling down a homogenizing signal are making
Appalachia as a clearly defined region disappear before our eyes,
according to longtime Appalachian watcher, minister and historian Bill
"Mass culture is overtaking it," Leonard said during a breakout session
at the 2011 annual meeting of the Cooperative Baptist Fellowship March
25 at First Baptist Church in Asheville, N.C.
Technology penetrates the isolation that gave Appalachian families,
churches and cultures its distinctive lilt. Now 24/7 "virtual religion"
flows down the crease of every holler, streaming into trailers and
cabins from sources as disparate as the prosperity gospel of TD Jakes
and Mike Murdoch, the sweet Catholic piety of Mother Angelica, the
strange new perspective of Mormons, the ubiquitous presence of the
Gaithers music and Joel Osteen "insisting God feels good about himself
and you should too."
"No single force is changing Appalachian church life like the
technology of televised religions," said Leonard, who is on sabbatical
as professor of church history from Wake Forest University School of
Leonard addressed the changing Appalachians because the Cooperative
Baptist Fellowship and other denominational groups are targeting the
region with social ministries they expect will lead to spiritual
development. Appalachia is a 1,600-mile long belt of mountains in
eastern North America that stretches southwest from the Gaspé Peninsula
in Quebec to the Gulf coastal plain in Alabama. Mount Mitchell (6,684
ft) in North Carolina's Black Mountains, just a few miles from where
Leonard was speaking, is the highest peak.
They currently, but less frequently, find distinctive branches of
faithful in the mountains, such as "No Hellers," who are Primitive
Baptist Universalists of no more than 1,000 members in 20 counties. They
"press their Calvinism to the logical conclusion -- or illogical --
that Christ's redemption is so powerful that all will be redeemed,"
Leonard said. They believe, "It's hell enough down here."
You will also find Pentecostal Holiness and those who will handle
snakes and drink poison, pressing the literalism of Jesus' words in Mark
16:18. Disagreements will surface between Trinitarian and "Jesus only"
theology. Leonard said denominationally connected churches, both in
rural areas and in town, thrived in Appalachia, "holding to a
fundamentalism that paralleled mountain sectarians."
King James remains the only "orthodox text" Leonard said, as he told of
one pastor relating a conflict in an associational meeting because "one
of the young preachers stood up and announced he was NIV positive."
More than any other distinctive religious expression, mountain religion
is tied to oral tradition, the centrality of religious experience and
the reality of the land," Leonard said, quoting Appalachian observer and writer Deborah McCauley.
The elements that give the Appalachian region is distinctiveness are
being hit hard by demographics, culture and destruction of the very
mountains that gave the religion its uniqueness. In the cultural
dilution, Appalachia is not immune from the "mega-churching of America,"
Leonard said. Such churches "may be doing for Appalachian ecclesiology
what Wal-Mart did for customer service. They rise on the edge of town,
draining the life from mom and pop churches."
The mega churches, along with virtual religions pumped into living rooms
from satellite dishes, are changing the expectations of church members
for what preaching, worship, music and evangelism should be like, he
said. On the other hand, these large churches also often provide
meaningful activities for aimless and unemployed youth.
Evangelicals are immune to the backlash that change prompts. Leonard
said an attempted book burning by Amazing Grace Baptist Church in
Canton, N.C., targeted writers and musicians like Rick Warren, Charles
Colson, Billy and Franklin Graham and the Gaithers. But, in good
Appalachian fashion, the church advertised that after the book burning
they would be serving fried chicken with all the sides.
A small but increasing presence of non-Christian religions is rising to
give the mountains a global flavor. Leonard sees storefront signs
alerting locals to the presence of the Islamic Society, Eckankar
meditation, yoga and Wiccan practitioners. Buddhists, Muslims or Hindus
run mom and pop motels throughout the region.
Environmental tragedies plague the region as forests disappear,
mountain tops are blown off and creeks fill with the sludge of open pit
mining. With few exceptions, Leonard said, the benefits promised to gain
acquiescence for the destructive practices never materialize and the
powerless populace is left with barren plateaus, poisoned water and
"Large pieces of religious culture are coming apart," Leonard said.
As an observer who has watched Appalachian distinctives crumble away
over decades, Leonard said it is important to remember Appalachia before
it disappears. He said the mountain churches "reflect the strength and
danger of sacraments and symbols."
Mountain religion can be dangerous, he said. River baptisms "can kill
you" if you're swept away by the frigid, fast moving water. Wine is
dangerous, whether purchased at Wal-Mart or poured from a backyard
source; foot washing is dangerous relationally because it is difficult
"to have ought against your brother or sister who is washing your feet."
Serpent handlers taught Leonard that "sacrament is alive, and it can
kill you. Every time you go to worship it is a matter of life and death.
That's fascinating to me."
"Generally speaking, Appalachian mountain churches refuse to civilize,
memorialize or intellectualize the life out of the means of grace," he
Such churches also demonstrate the power of oral tradition and the
strength of story. While mountain preachers may seem semi-literate to
pedigreed flatlanders, some have committed large amounts of scripture to
memory and have "amazing pulpit skills."
Appalachian religious communities embody an ability to acknowledge "sacred space" Leonard said, "and reclaim it when lost."
But as strip mines and strip malls, slag pits and condo complexes,
polluted rivers and manhandled mountains mark the Appalachians, those
sacred spaces are washing down the mountains like so much sludge.
"If Jesus continues to tarry and the mountains continue to vanish and
the Church on Earth remains asleep then somebody ought to try and wake
it up," Leonard said. "Before we all have to learn to sing the Lord's
song in a treeless and mountainless land."