Talking about contraception

March 20, 2012

Who would have thought that contraception would become such a
major issue in this election year?

Or is it?

The U.S. Catholic bishops stress that the issue
is not really contraception but religious liberty--the right of Catholics, and
by extension any group of religious people, to practice and live out their
faith. That's a plausible argument, as the Century
editors acknowledged a few weeks ago, and
it is certainly one designed to gain allies among other religious people.

But at some point the bishops might wonder if pressing that
argument to the extent that they have--refusing what to many of us seems like a reasonable compromise--really serves the
church's interests.

In invoking their rights to avoid having anything to do with
contraception, the bishops avoid the more difficult theological challenge:
winsomely explaining the church's stance on contraception.

The Catholic Church has a powerful and interesting argument.
It asserts that contraception undermines the proper nature of sexual
intercourse by separating its unitive and procreative dimensions. In other
words, the delights of sex always need to be entwined with baby-making.
Otherwise sexual intercourse loses its divine meaning.

Though it seems that few Christians, Catholic or Protestant,
are persuaded by this argument, it remains intellectually important and
instructive. Indeed, the best Protestant theologians by and large keep the
terms of the argument and simply offer a more complex and nuanced understanding
of how the procreative and unitive dimensions can be defined and how they can
relate to each other.

At some point the bishops might want to assess the impact of
their witness to the culture on this issue. Have they done anything to help a
skeptical secular world--and skeptical members of their own churches--better
understand and respect the church's traditional view of sex? Or have they
reinforced the view of many that the hierarchy is not much interested in that
work, and not well equipped for it--but it is skilled at marshalling political
clout? The bishops may win a political battle but pay a large price for their
victory.

That final point, by the way, can apply to many religious
activists, not just the Catholic bishops.