The CEB and the disciple who barely escaped

October 26, 2011

As a disciple left the Jerusalem Temple complex,
he urged Jesus to look. "What large stones and what large buildings!" the
disciple says in the NRSV (Mark 13:1). But "large" seems too weak a word. The
new Common English Bible translates
the line, "What awesome stones and buildings!" That adjective is a better
choice (though it's been watered down in recent years).

Whenever a new Bible translation comes out, questions arise about
changes to familiar passages. I was pleased to see the CEB use the word
"disciple" to refer to the mysterious young man who appears in Mark 14:51-52,
after the 12 disciples desert Jesus and run away:

One young man, a
disciple, was wearing nothing but a linen cloth. They grabbed him, but he left
the linen cloth behind and ran away naked.

The Greek word for "disciple" is not in the
text--but there is a verb indicating he was a follower who was risking arrest
himself.

Mark later describes a "young man" wearing a
white robe and sitting on the right side inside the empty tomb when the three
women enter--the only witness to the resurrection recorded in Mark's gospel
(with its original ending at 16:8). He tells the women to inform Peter and the
disciples to go to Galilee, where they will see the risen Jesus--but the women
are so "overcome with terror and dread" (CEB) that they flee from the tomb and
tell no one.

Mark doesn't say that these two passages feature
the same young man. But it's
interesting that Mark's Gospel, unlike the others in the canon, does not have
the risen Jesus appear to the 12 disciples--and that it does feature numerous
unnamed witnesses, separate from the 12 and Jesus's family, to his healings and
teachings and death.

Emerson B. Powery, the Greek associate editor
for the CEB, said in an e-mail interview that the young man who barely escaped
arrest "is exactly the kind of representative who is part of this larger group
of disciples 'around Jesus' who were following along closely." People around
Jesus, along with the 12, were even given the secret to God's kingdom
(4:10-11).

Powery, who has a doctorate from Duke, teaches
at Messiah College in Pennsylvania. Asked about CEB passages likely to draw
interest, Powery noted that Mary's surprised reaction to the angel ("I haven't
had sexual relations") is accurate and less theological than the NRSV's use of
"virgin" (Luke 1:34). "Throughout the Gospel of John," he said, "the NRSV's
general use of 'the Jews' is usually, in the CEB, translated as the more
specific 'Jewish leaders,' or 'Jewish opposition' or 'Jewish authorities.'" And
the "Son of man" becomes "the Human One"--a translation decision far too
complex to deal with here.