How religious right is Rick Perry?
The conventional wisdom is
that the Republican primary race's frontrunners are now Mitt Romney, Michele
Bachmann and Rick Perry. Jon Stewart thinks this analysis is unfair to Ron Paul,
who placed second to Bachmann in the Ames Straw Poll on Saturday. While Paul's
libertarian ideas helped fuel the Tea Party, Stewart dismisses Bachmann and
Perry as "Moral Majority in a tri-corner hat."
This aside from Stewart echoes
Andrew Sullivan's claim that Bachmann and Perry's prominence
amounts to a "Christianist takeover" of the GOP primary, evidence that
small-government conservatism continues to be pushed out by a more religious
variety, as he argued in The Conservative
Soul. Of course, the rise of the Tea Party makes that 2006 book seem less
The Tea Party's energy is
primarily antitax and antigovernment. A lot of Tea Partiers are also religious
conservatives, but not because the movement was infiltrated by the almighty
religious right. It's because economic and social conservatism have a lot more genuine overlap than many commentators think.
Enter Michele Bachmann, who's had little trouble positioning herself as a
leader on both fronts.
But what about Perry? We've
heard a lot about him since he announced his campaign Saturday: Is he or isn't he smart enough to win? Is he just like George W. Bush, or does he just seem
that way to non-Texans? And is he the hardcore religious-right type
some would have us believe?
Perry's been aggressively reaching out to conservative evangelicals,
even sponsoring a prayer-themed political spectacle in Houston.
But while this could be read simply as an existing prayer warrior's splashy
jump to a national stage, it also smacks of trying too hard--as if Perry hopes
that all the religious conservatives who just started paying attention to him
will assume he's always shared their priorities.
It isn't clear whether he has.
Erica Grieder makes a strong case that Perry is far more
motivated by economic causes than by social ones. And his ideas about the role
of government and federal spending are pretty wild. Most campaign books are
about courage and resolve and the American dream; Perry's is about how
basically everything the federal government has ever spent money on
Mainstream conservative economists revere Milton Friedman; Perry says
that acting on Friedman's ideas would amount to treason.
Yes, Perry talks the
religious-right talk. Every serious national Republican candidate in my
lifetime has done this. But while Perry presents plenty of causes for alarm,
it's not at all clear that his religious views deserve a top spot on this list.