On the Shelf

Blogging: Subculture or mainstream?

blogging about blogging can be the ultimate navel-gazing, but hear me out; I
mean to intrigue.

a well-written book on cyberculture theory, Pramod K. Nayar claims that blogs
"have become a folk cultural form." So far so good. But most of Nayar's other
descriptions of blogging seem a bit dated: it's life-writing or autobiography,
it's an online diary, it's inherently personal, it's subcultural. All this may
have been true once, but most of the blogs I read have grown up and taken on
new form and function.

grants that "blogs are perhaps no longer subcultural considering their
heterogeneity, numbers, and expanding use on the World Wide Web." But he
doesn't elaborate on developments such as

  • Newspaper sites that sponsor and
    host bloggers (see Bruce Reyes-Chow's connection with
    the San Francisco Chronicle)
  • Blogs such as Time magazine's Swampland, which is updated
    multiple times daily by well-known reporters with off-the-cuff thoughts and
    developing stories
  • Networks of independent
    bloggers, such as the Century's CCblogs network,
    of which my blog is a member

pastors are now blogging on church websites, and columnists publish more formal
content in print and more casual stuff on blogs (though the distinction isn't
always so clear). Blogs have grown out of their subcultural status, moving from
a form of journaling or life-casting to a powerful mainstream tool for
expression and dialogue.

suggests that blogs are "filling in the gaps" in public discourse. While he doesn't
elaborate, the phrase is spot on. Blogging fills the gaps that existed ten
years ago between professional journalism and thoughtful personal journaling. As
the gaps are filled, the distinctions are becoming less clear. Subculture has
become mainstream, and a new folk cultural form evolves.

Adam J. Copeland

Adam J. Copeland is director of the Center for Stewardship Leaders at Luther Seminary in St. Paul, Minnesota. His blog is part of the CCblogs network.

All articles »