On the shelf: The Unlikely Disciple, by Kevin Roose

July 16, 2009

"I'm aware that a tree-hugging Brown student isn't supposed to be able
to talk to a Bible-thumping Liberty student," writes Kevin Roose. "But
why not? Aren't we all part of the Millennial generation? Don't we all
carry the same iPhones and suffer from the same entitlement complex?"

Roose's sentiment echoes Mark Pinsky in A Jew Among the Evangelicals. The Unlikely Disciple
chronicles a project similar to that book's: understanding and
humanizing conservative evangelicals for the benefit of left-leaning
secular folks (see my review
of Pinsky's book). Roose's approach is to go undercover: he leaves his
Ivy League campus to spend a semester at Liberty University.

His
account of the experience is nuanced, respectful and personal. Roose
details the painless and painful aspects of adapting to his new climate,
the pleasant and unpleasant ways in which his new classmates surprise
him and the helpful and unhelpful responses from his liberal family and
friends. He continually renegotiates the ethics of going undercover, of
acting out rather than trying out conservative evangelicalism.

This,
too, proves complicated. Roose finds himself drawn into the life he's
leading, internalizing its attitudes without buying into the larger
implications. Drawing from anthropologist Susan Harding, he notes that
religious conversion is in part the acquisition of a particular
language—and he finds himself partly converted.

This self-aware
enculturation makes for provocative reading. Roose is struck by how much
easier it is to enjoy a conversation with a female student when he
knows that a sexual encounter is not on the agenda. When his lesbian
aunts express concern over students' homophobia, he observes that his
Liberty friends are no more walking stereotypes than his aunts are, and
when he tells his Liberty friends that he's returning to Brown, most
infer a crisis of faith and offer to pray with him: "It's the most
passive-aggressive Inquisition trial in history."

The book's
weaknesses are minor, typically mistakes reflecting Roose's newness to
the evangelical world. He indicates that rapture theology wasn't in the
evangelical mainstream until the Left Behind books. I wish this were true—I might have been spared many nightmares and anxiety episodes courtesy of Larry Norman and Russell S. Doughten.

More
significantly, as a Wheaton graduate I puzzled at Roose's suggestion
that in the early '70s a "fully accredited, academically rigorous"
school was "novel in the world of conservative evangelicalism." Of
course, conservatism is relative, and Wheaton, Calvin and Westmont were
never rigid enough for Liberty founder Jerry Falwell.

Still, I
was struck by how much of Roose's description echoes my own experience
at Wheaton. Liberty's academic life is dominated by a tension between
serious inquiry and a priori commitments. Come spring, someone
posts a note asking women to take responsibility for male sexuality by
dressing more modestly. Students take dates to formal banquets but don't
dance; one student arrives at Liberty carrying business cards for
potential suitors. While outright aggression toward gays and lesbians is
rare, low-grade homophobia is ubiquitous. So are alternate swear words
(e.g., "flipping"), "G-rated mischief" and Joshua Harris. All this is familiar to me.

The
book's saddest episode is a spring break trip to Daytona Beach to do
some confrontational evangelism. In a prayer time between day and
evening outreach excursions, we see both the misguidedness of such an
approach and the startling hostility of those it targets:

"I
pray, Lord, for the old man who spit on me," says Charlotte, a blonde
from Arkansas. "Satan had such a strong grip on him, and I just want to
see him know you, Lord."

Claire is the last to pray: "Lord, let them be nicer to us tonight."

It's
a conflict between two very different groups of young people, though
with equally depressing spring break plans. Perhaps Roose's book will
help to bridge this gap.

(An excerpt
of Roose's book, in which he tells of getting and conducting the last
print interview with Falwell before he died, is posted on Relevant magazine's site. The resulting article, written for Liberty's student paper, is here.)