Not quite Screwtape

December 29, 2010

In mock
letters of advice from a convert to godlessness, Eberstadt tells the
"major-league atheist guys" (Richard Dawkins, Sam Harris, Christopher Hitchens et al.) how they need to firm up their
arguments. This is a breezy take on Screwtape
Letters
, voiced by a beleaguered 20-something atheist who can't help
noticing that the believers ("Dulls," in atheist-speak) have some pretty good
evidence on their side.

Just look at
the record when it comes to great art, good deeds and defending human dignity,
for example. Better to avoid those topics, she counsels:

 

The Dulls not only do this charitable
stuff because their backward books tell them to; they also think that helping
the weak is a good thing to do just in and of itself. As long as they persist
in believing such an unnatural thing, it will be hard for us Atheists to bring
them in by promising that the unbelievers do better at this game. They're
stupid, yes--but not that stupid.

Eberstadt's setup makes it a bit too easy for her to score
ideological points. Indeed, her fondness for her counterarguments to the
atheists offers a sharp contrast to the appealing humility of C. S. Lewis's
approach in Screwtape, with its
piercing perception of how the devil's arguments get inside all of us. But it's
a lively effort, and she is especially effective in suggesting how the New
Atheism might sound to youth who grew up in a culture of atheism.