The endurance of rural congregations

December 6, 2010

little rural church I serve, along with two other retired clergy, has
two dozen members, if you carefully count everyone whether there or
not.  No one is young.  The church growth gang (now called church
transformation) calls it a declining and dying congregation.  The thing
is, it's been there for over a hundred years and has never had more than
a couple dozen members.  People come, people go, people die, people
come.  Now and then it has tolerated clergy attempting to be full time,
but, for the most part, it has got along fine with a long line of supply

now they have the services of three experienced, well respected pastors
who provide both continuity and variety.  A skeptical colleague
wondered out loud about how long they will last when we are gone.  My
guess is at least another hundred years.  Fifty years before I came on
the scene they were served by a local professor who was also an
Episcopal priest.  Others have included clergy skilled in mission work,
new clergy trying out their wings, another professor, and even a high
church priest who may have been the only one who knew what to do with a

all be beside the point.  Small rural congregations don't really depend
on seminary educated clergy.  It's nice to have them, but not a
necessity.  They don't even depend on a flow of new families with young
children.  They do depend on the economic viability of the towns they
are in.  Dying towns beget dying congregations.  But if a town can
sustain itself, an otherwise healthy, small rural congregation will just
keep on going.  It has more to do with the spirit of the place and the
Spirit that fills it than with experts on church growth and

might be the nature of that Spirit filled spirit?  From what I can
tell, it is the genuine love and care between members, and for the
community, that transcend the petty irritants of small town life in
which there are no secrets.  It's the joy of worshiping whether with or
without music.  It's the making of parish decisions, sometimes with more
than a little contention, right in the midst of a Sunday morning
service.  It's the embrace of whomever comes in the door, no matter who
they are, with a naive lack of awareness that their embrace may be more
than a stranger desires or can stand.  It's the genuine concern for
others in the community who are suffering or in need.

requires one more thing. It requires an openness to a subtle indwelling
of the Holy Spirit. By subtle presence I mean an atmosphere of the
Spirit's presence, unseen and unheard, yet there.  I don't think you can
make that happen whether by loud proclamation or through sophisticated
A small rural congregation without that subtle presence may indeed be
declining and dying, and we have all seen that happen.  One with that
subtle presence will probably continue from generation to generation as
long as there are generations to be had. 

Originally posted at Country Parson.


Thank you, thank you, Steve,

Thank you, thank you, Steve, for your respect and insight. I've been serving one of those "dying" congregations for about a year now, and have learned a lot about Christian community. I too expect that my little congregation-- I'm officially 1/4 time there-- will go on for another hundred years at least. Thanks again for your witness that there's more than one way to be a faithful church.


As a tentmaker, I serve a similar congregation. The Spirit is a palpable presence and we are blessed in many ways that members of "healthy" congregations may never know.

Small numbers/rural congregations and their survival

Being a member of a small town congregation, I sometimes wonder if we're not all wrong about development, about growth, about numbers. How blessed it is to be able to witness others in their joy, sorrow, poor health, celebration on a face to face weekly basis. Not a congregation where one leaves thinking "who were those new people? I wonder if anyone greeted them?" Small groups, Bible studies, breakout sessions - in so many ways we yearn for smaller yet we continue to judge ourselves by numbers only. There's so much more to Christ's words than counting....thanks CP for your insight!


Your insights are right on! As a small church pastor most of my life I can tell you that many of the congregations the "experts" think are on the way out will still be around for a long time. I was trained in the church growth school of thought and have spoken on the topic of church growth and the small church. The mistake some church growth thinkers make is that they have never really gotten acquainted with the smaller congregations to understand their dynamics. Thanks for the great post.

Terry Reed
Small Church Tools