Political Islam on defensive across the Middle East

The backlash against Muslim Brother­hood rule in Egypt comes as secular forces across the Middle East are rising up in opposition to political Islam. Divisions reach from top leaders to the street.

Political leaders in Saudi Arabia, United Arab Emirates, Kuwait and Jordan have sided with the Egyptian military and secularists who backed the July 3 ouster of President Mohamed Morsi.

On the streets of Cairo, mobs and snipers have attacked Morsi supporters, forcing security forces accused of slaughtering the Islamists to stand between them and the mob. The violence in Egypt echoes similar, though less deadly, backlashes against Islamic ruling parties in Tunisia and Turkey.

“The Egyptian uprising two years ago was against the Egyptian army,” says Michael Rubin, a Middle East expert at the American Enterprise Institute. But after one year of Muslim Brotherhood rule, “suddenly (Egyptians) are coming out in the streets seeing the army as their savior.”

Egypt’s anti-Brotherhood uprising had caused at one point at least 900 deaths in clashes. On August 19, some 25 policemen were killed by masked gunmen on the Sinai Peninsula, an area of frequent clashes between Islamist militants and security forces.

The turmoil in Egypt came after the May-June protests in Turkey against what protesters there described as the creeping authoritarianism of that country’s ruling party and its president, Recep Tayyip Erdoğan.

In Tunisia, the birthplace of the Arab Spring, the Islamist Ennhada party has been deadlocked with secularists demanding that it step aside and allow a caretaker government to take charge.

Secularists emboldened by Morsi’s ouster in Egypt took to the streets there weeks ago after the assassination of a second secularist politician this year by Islamist gunmen.

“We’ve seen a backlash against the first wave of political actors of the immediate post-revolutionary moment,” says Robert Satloff, executive director of the Washington Institute for Near East Policy. Whether secularists “are making a play everywhere” is unclear, Satloff says, and Gulf states are following their own national interests.

Gulf states, led by Saudi Arabia, are supporting the Egyptian military against the Muslim Brotherhood in Egypt. But they are also supporting the Brotherhood in other arenas, such as Syria, where Brotherhood and other Islamist fighters are trying to topple a Shi‘ite- and Iranian-backed tyrant, Bashar al-Assad.

The Gulf states want stability and to counter Shi‘ite expansion in Syria and Iraq, so they support Islamists when it fits their national interests, Satloff says. “If you’re looking for consistency, this is not the region to do it,” he notes.

Arab kings and sheikhs are speaking out in support of secular civil society and against Islamists because “they know that eventually the Brotherhood will go after them” too, says Walid Phares, author of the book The Coming Revolution: Struggle for Freedom in the Middle East. “It would be a better deal to recognize civil society little by little than to fall all at once to the Muslim Brotherhood and other Islamists.”

The conflict between secularists and Islamists is also generating a new religious dialogue about the role of religion in politics, something many in the West have said is needed since the 9/11 terrorist attacks on the United States, Phares said.

Grand sheikh Ahmed al-Tayeb of Cairo’s al-Azhar University urged Brotherhood members to renounce violence and said his institution would resist political efforts to influence religious scholars, according to a translation by Egyptian newspaper Al-Masry Al-Youm.

“Religious non-Islamist leaders of the Arab world want free of the sphere of the Muslim Brotherhood,” Phares said.

Aaron Zelin, who edits Jihadology, a blog that archives primary source jihadi documents, says the Arab uprising has led people across the region to speak and act when they feel wronged by their leaders, but it’s far too early to count the Islamists out.

The military crackdown in Egypt has brought together all the strands of Islamists, causing ultraconservative Salafists to join with jihadists in backing the nonviolent Brotherhood, Zelin said. All want an Islamist state, and they see the crackdown as an affront against them all.

“They’re taking a beating now, but they’ll be back,” Zelin says. —USA Today


This article was edited on August 31, 2013.

To post a comment, log inregister, or use the Facebook comment box.